If you want to heat your home, it might be tempting to go with the gas heating system. Gas heating offers the most efficient way to heat your home, with efficiency ratings as high as 97%.
However, if you are looking for low maintenance and a cost-effective alternative, an electric heating system might be better. Electric heating systems also provide more energy than gas heaters. To better understand the two, this guide provides a vivid comparison for you to study and purchase the suitable one.
Similarities Between Gas and Electric Heaters
1. Heating Efficiency
Although the actual efficiency of each one differs, both gas and electric heaters have a heating efficiency rating of 80-90%. Also, both of them can heat a large area while using the same amount of energy. Therefore, if you have a home with many rooms, both electric and gas heaters can be installed to provide comfort to every room.
2. Installation Cost
Gas and electric heaters have similar installation costs for homes or offices. The only major difference is an additional line for a gas heater. At the same time, electric heating systems do not require an additional power line as long as it is located near the electrical outlet.
3. Timeless Functions
Gas and electric heating systems are also able to work without the need for maintenance. The only difference is that gas heaters need to be turned off and on manually while electric heating systems can be controlled remotely.
4. Heating Modes
Both gas and electric heaters offer a range of heating modes to suit your specific needs. Your pre-heated rooms can be maintained by setting them up in energy-saving mode. Instant heat can also be activated each time you need it without worrying about cutting costs. You may also adjust the temperature level to fit your needs.
5. Energy Consumption
Space heating is one of the most common uses of energy in homes and offices. Gas heaters consume more energy because they require more fuel to operate. Apart from that, you would also need to use more energy if you turn your heating system on during the colder months to provide warmth. On the other hand, electric heaters operate at low temperatures, are much quieter and require less energy.
Differences Between Gas and Electric Heaters
1. Life Span
Electric heating systems tend to last for as long as 25-30 years, while gas heaters have a shorter lifespan of 10-15 years. Gas heaters require replacement after 15 years due to the corrosive elements in the heaters. While electric heating systems have a longer life, they require frequent maintenance.
2. Repair Cost
Gas heaters have a higher repair cost than electric heaters due to their unique parts. Unsurprisingly, some parts would require replacement every year. However, this doesn’t happen that often with an electric heater.
3. Environmental Impact
The life span of gas and electric heating systems is also affected by environmental factors and external conditions such as temperature and humidity levels. Gas heaters generally last longer because they don’t require enough maintenance. Also, gas heaters release toxic elements into the atmosphere. On the other hand, electric heating systems have a low emissions rate and require less maintenance than gas heaters.
Top Brands for Gas & Electric Heaters
Rinnai is a company that specializes in manufacturing gas heaters. This brand offers more than 35 years of experience in the industry. They have several heaters to suit your heating needs, from wall-mounted models to radiant floor heating systems. Rinnai’s products are known for their efficiency, reliability and durability.
Heatilator is a company that deals in manufacturing and distributing electric heaters. Many of their products are certified by a third-party testing company called Underwriter Laboratories Inc. (UL). Heatilator’s products have been around since 1954 that also gives it an edge over its competitors. It has become one of the most reputable manufacturers in the industry and offers UL-listed products to cater to many different needs.
Primus is a Chinese manufacturer that specializes in manufacturing gas heaters. This brand is well-known for its high-quality products. Its main products include gas, electric and forced hot air heaters. The company has made partnerships with Rinnai and Heatilator to offer more products.
4. Split Air
Split Air is a Chinese manufacturer that specializes in manufacturing electric heaters. Its heaters are known for their high efficiency, with the heat energy being more than 70% and 80%. It also offers efficient products without noise pollution. Being one of the biggest players in the industry, Split Air has been able to offer complete solutions for your home comfort needs.
Electric and gas heaters have both their pros and cons, making it hard to make a decision. However, if you look at the life span, repair cost, energy consumption and environmental impact, electric heating systems seem to be the better option. While gas heaters require replacement after 15-20 years, electric heating systems can last a lifetime. Additionally, gas heaters also release toxic gases into the atmosphere, while electric heating systems don’t require maintenance.